Controversial Research Casts Doubt on Long COVID
"My life has literally just stopped."
That's what one person suffering from long COVID told the Lancashire Telegraph in March 2024 — more than three years after she first got COVID-19.
Long COVID, or post-COVID-19, has been recognized by the World Health Organization, with sufferers feeling symptoms such as fatigue, shortness of breath, and difficulty with mental focus months after infection.
March 15 was Long COVID Awareness Day. But it was also the day an Australian doctor told the media that the term "long COVID" is "misleading" and "harmful" — because while the symptoms are real, people don't experience them any more frequently than they do for other respiratory viruses.
His comments have angered those who have spent months and years suffering.
The doctor is John Gerrard, the chief health officer of the state of Queensland in Australia. He and his team of researchers surveyed more than 5,000 people who had symptoms of respiratory illness in May and June 2022.
Of the people surveyed, about 2,400 tested positive for COVID, and nearly 1,000 tested positive for influenza. The rest were negative for both, but did have symptoms of some kind of respiratory illness.
A year later, the participants were asked about their symptoms. About 16% said they were suffering ongoing symptoms, with 3.6% saying their daily lives were moderately to severely affected.
And while 3% of those who had had COVID said they were still moderately to severely affected by their symptoms, among those who hadn't had COVID, it was 4%.
"We found that the rates of ongoing symptoms and functional impairment are indistinguishable from other post-viral illnesses," Gerrard said.
In the researchers' opinion, he added, using terms like "long COVID" can cause "unnecessary fear" that might even impede recovery.
However, UK news website The Canary criticized Gerrard, and suggested that the release of the research was intended to "discredit and gaslight" long COVID patients.
The full study hasn't yet been published, but a summary has been released. The full results are due to be presented at a conference in April.